Sole trader or company: how does your structure change the insurance you need?
As a sole trader you and your business are the same legal person, so a claim against the business is a claim against you and can reach your personal assets — insurance is what stands between the two. A company is a separate legal entity whose shareholders generally aren't liable for its debts, but its directors carry personal duties, including under health and safety law. Both need the same core covers; a company should also look at cover for its directors.
How do they compare?
| Sole trader | Limited company | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal person | You. The business has no separate legal existence. | The company is a separate legal entity (Companies Act 1993). |
| Personal assets exposed to business claims | Yes. | Generally not for shareholders; directors can be personally liable for their own breaches of duty. |
| Who the policy insures | You, trading under your name or trading name. | The company; directors and employees only as the wording extends cover to them. |
| Extra cover to consider | — | Directors and officers / management liability; statutory liability that extends to directors. |
Does a company protect me from claims?
Partly. Limited liability protects shareholders from the company's debts, but it doesn't stop a director being pursued personally for a breach of their own duties. Under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015, directors and other officers have a personal due-diligence duty (section 44) and can be prosecuted individually. Directors and officers (D&O) or management liability cover exists for this exposure. The Companies Act 1993 limits when a company may indemnify or insure its directors, so the policy needs to be set up properly.
What changes if I move from sole trader to company?
The insured changes. Your policies name you as a sole trader; once the company trades, the company needs to be the insured. Tell your insurer or adviser before you incorporate. For claims-made covers like professional indemnity, ask how work you did as a sole trader will be covered after the change — the retroactive date matters.
Common questions
Do sole traders need different insurance from companies?
The core covers are the same — public liability, professional indemnity if you give advice, property and tools, vehicles. What differs is whose assets are at risk and whether directors need cover of their own.
Does ACC cover me as a sole trader?
ACC covers accidental injury for everyone in NZ, and self-employed people pay ACC levies. ACC doesn't cover illness or your business's liability to others.
Is directors and officers insurance compulsory?
No. It is optional cover for directors' personal exposure.
Sources
- Companies Act 1993
- Health and Safety at Work Act 2015, section 44 (officers' due diligence)
- Accident Compensation Act 2001
Related
- Sole trader insurance NZ
- Statutory liability vs employer liability
- Professional indemnity insurance
- Insurance for freelancers
General information, not personalised financial advice. Policy wordings differ between insurers and products; your policy wording and schedule decide what applies. SmallBusinessInsurance.co.nz is operated by Evolve Group Limited (FSP711891), a licensed Financial Advice Provider. Business-insurance enquiries are referred to Blanket Advice Limited (FSP1004126), a separately licensed Financial Advice Provider.
Not sure which you need?
Tell us about your business and a licensed adviser will be in touch.
Get quotes