Statutory liability vs employer liability: what's the difference in NZ?
Statutory liability responds when a regulator prosecutes your business for an unintentional breach of a statute — it pays defence costs and some fines, and HSWA reparation where that is lawful to insure, but not HSWA fines, which cannot be insured. Employer liability responds when an employee sues you over a work injury that ACC doesn't cover. A single serious workplace incident can trigger both.
How do they compare?
| Statutory liability | Employer liability | |
|---|---|---|
| Who comes after you | A regulator or prosecutor — WorkSafe, or another agency enforcing a statute. | Your own employee (or their family), in a civil claim. |
| What it pays (Vero BusinessPlan) | Defence costs, insurable fines, and reparation ordered after an HSWA prosecution to the extent it is lawful to insure. | Defence costs and damages for an employee's personal injury — including mental injury — that ACC does not cover. |
| What it does not pay | Fines, penalties or infringement fees under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015. | Anything ACC covers; personal grievances such as unjustified dismissal (exclusion 5); injury arising from sexual harassment. |
| Typical trigger | A WorkSafe prosecution after a workplace incident; a Fair Trading Act or Privacy Act breach. | A claim for exemplary damages, or for an injury outside ACC's definitions. |
Can insurance pay a WorkSafe fine?
No. Section 29 of the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 makes it unlawful to insure against, or be indemnified for, a fine or infringement fee under that Act. Vero's statutory liability wording reflects this: its definition of "Fine" leaves out HSWA fines but allows HSWA reparation where that is lawful to insure. What statutory liability can still pay after a WorkSafe prosecution is your defence costs and, where lawful, reparation to the victim.
"a fine, penalty or infringement fee paid or which becomes due to be paid under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 (or any replacement Act) and any subsequent amendments on or after 5 May 2003"
What does employer liability actually cover in NZ?
Less than the name suggests, because ACC covers most workplace injury on a no-fault basis and largely bars suing for it. Employer liability fills the gap: claims for exemplary damages, and injuries outside ACC's cover. Vero's wording defines personal injury for this section to include "mental anguish or mental injury", but excludes injury arising from sexual harassment or sexual abuse.
It is not cover for employment disputes. Vero excludes "claims arising directly or indirectly out of the unjustifiable dismissal of any employee or other personal grievance arising out of a contract of employment" (Employers liability exclusion 5). Personal grievances need Employment Practices Liability, usually part of a management liability policy.
Do I need both?
If you have employees, they cover different people coming after you for the same event: the regulator (statutory liability) and the injured worker (employer liability). In Vero's BusinessPlan both are optional sections of the same package. Whether you need either, and at what limit, depends on your industry and headcount — a licensed adviser can work that through with you.
Common questions
Does statutory liability cover directors personally?
It depends on the wording and who is named as insured. Directors and officers have their own due-diligence duty under the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015 and can be prosecuted personally. Check whether your statutory liability section extends to directors, or whether you need directors and officers cover.
Is employer liability insurance compulsory in NZ?
No. Neither employer liability nor statutory liability insurance is legally required. Employers must pay ACC levies, which is a different thing.
Are ACC levies the same as employer liability insurance?
No. ACC levies fund the no-fault ACC scheme and are compulsory. Employer liability is optional private insurance for the injury claims ACC leaves open.
Sources
- Vero BusinessPlan policy wording VBWBSP 07/24 (effective 1 July 2024) — PDF
- Health and Safety at Work Act 2015, section 29 (prohibition on insuring fines) and section 44 (officers' due diligence)
- Accident Compensation Act 2001
Related
- Employer liability insurance NZ
- Statutory liability cost
- ACC vs employer liability
- WorkSafe, HSWA and insurance
General information, not personalised financial advice. Policy wordings differ between insurers and products; your policy wording and schedule decide what applies. SmallBusinessInsurance.co.nz is operated by Evolve Group Limited (FSP711891), a licensed Financial Advice Provider. Business-insurance enquiries are referred to Blanket Advice Limited (FSP1004126), a separately licensed Financial Advice Provider.
Not sure which you need?
Tell us about your business and a licensed adviser will be in touch.
Get quotes